Maybe it’s time to consider how to bring back the Sunday Roast, or at least how to carve out time every week for a special meal. As a hard core grilling enthusiast I was very skeptical about trying this on a beautiful ribeye we bought to enjoy for a Christmas Eve Dinner. I did replace the canola oil with avocado oil, and I didn’t have fresh herbs, but it was still phenomenal. Few days ago, my son fell in love with garlic butter on the steak at local restaurant. Followed this to the letter and ended up with absolutely delicious steaks!! Perfect timing for steaks. My this for daughter and son in law. The cooling rack will keep the crispy, crusty browned meat from getting soggy sitting in its own juices. 1st time my steaks turned out cooking them inside! Beautiful seat in the cast iron, too. Use a digital thermometer to decide when they are a couple degrees shy of your target temperature. Enjoy. If you are just going to say ok then why even comment?!? My wife says she never wants to have a steak any other way. … Usually, they're cut into smaller, more practical sizes for retail. I may even get on the mushroom trend. I used a boneless ribeye and it was tender and juicy. Loved it! Cook it in the oven to fully enjoy its flavor. I never leave reviews, but this steak was amazing! For a bone-in prime rib, figure two servings per rib, while a boneless roast will yield two servings per pound. baking pan with the mirepoix and rest the meat on top. Bone-in ribeye is more flaverful than boneless. Next time, I’ll reduce the cooking time by a minute or two. With the bones removed, you’ll be able to slice roast as thick (or thin) as you’d like. I never heard not to until like 3 months ago. I second Chungah’s comment that ribeye steak can be boneless or bone-in. Should be 155°. Cooking bone-in prime rib roast in the oven is easy; a hot sear followed by slow roasting at a low temperature delivers outstanding results. Buy rib eye steaks, which is sliced rib eye roast. And it was super easy and not intimidating, even when working with rib eye. I tried this recipe but it was a failure. Fill a 13×9-in. This roast is well-marbled and the fat melts into the roast as it cooks, leaving you with a flavorful, tender beef roast. I will have meals for 3 days! Prime rib roasts are often measured by the number of rib bones you get in your cut. If with bone does it longer. Loved the herb garlic butter! Roast to desired doneness, following the chart below for the perfect boneless prime rib cooking time. This gives the juices time to absorb into the meat. Removing extra moisture helps the steak brown better, which equals more flavor. Normally I do not. I had to use a regular pan and didn’t have the rosemary and thyme but it was still so amazing I can’t even imagine it being better. My husband said it was the best steak he had ever had. The taste was delicious; however, it was overcooked. This was ABSOLUTELY the best steak I have ever cooked at home. I’m an Aussie and that’s how we are used to buying them too. Although you can make some pretty spectacular dinners with these ingredients, they’ll never be met with the same kind of celebratory excitement that comes from roasting a big, juicy cut like prime rib. Cover and process until it’s blended. This takes the chill off the meat surface, which aids in browning. Absolutely delicious! So skip the expensive steakhouse this Valentine’s Day. I would suggest turning it four times before reducing heat and spooning the butter over the meat. Damn delicious. Place the steak in the middle of the skillet and cook, turning every 2-3 minutes, until a dark crust has formed on both sides, about 12-14 minutes. Haha, I always use a cast iron on my stove top. So damn delicious! Cook the roast for 15 minutes, then reduce the oven temperature to 325 degrees. Prime rib is sourced from the rib section of a cow, an area that’s extra tender and marbled with fat. Heat a medium cast iron skillet over medium high heat until very hot, about 1-2 minutes; add canola oil. This is going to be an excellent surprise for him this week end ! I really enjoyed preparing this steak. Do not skimp on the fresh herbs! The end result was fabulous! It would essentially be like our reverse sear, but with an even lower temp and without the sear at the end. Thanks! You don’t know much about steaks do you Karen?! Perfectly crusted with foaming warm butter infused with smashed garlic cloves and fresh thyme + rosemary sprigs. For a shortcut, you can definitely use a pre-made mix, but it’s easy enough to make your own from scratch. Thank you! Boneless would follow this recipe. 2 inch cut, 3 mins a side, butter baste for 3 mins, perfect medium rare. it 5 stars before trying but it looks oh so good. Will definitely do this again (but on a date where I can impress ;)). I followed your recipe except I cut the time almost in half since our ribeye was only 1 1/2” vs the 2” you had in your recipe. Prime. Check out the price of a tomahawk ribeye sometime! Slice and eat. Cooking Ribeye Roast in the OvenPreheat oven to 350°F.Make an herb rub for the ribeye. document.head.appendChild(chicscript); Marbling is what makes all the difference to the taste buds. Go for bone-in beef. Cover the ribeye roast with the herb rub, coating well.Place the roast into a large roasting pan. Agreed, making it well done completely ruins such a great cut of meat. Let it sit at room temperature about 30 minutes before roasting. It came out fabulous and amazingly tender! I will try them next time just for the out of body experience. If you want well done, and still good, you should be looking at a strip steak. OMG…OMG. (For an 8 pound roast that's 40 minutes). Required fields are marked *, Your Rating * Used safflower oil in cast iron. Our local butcher sells them to us with the bone-in. Excellent Sunday dinner with wine! Great with steamed rice! I’ll start by searing the steak and finishing it in the oven when the steak reaches 125 I remove from the oven and from the pan putting the steak on a cooling rack over a plate or pan to catch the drippings. Try it sometime. Average This will “wet” down the seasoning so it’s easy to spread on your rib roast. Their extra surface area prevents the temperature from rising too quickly, making sure your roast is nice and juicy. Let rest 15 minutes before slicing. Remember, your roast will … Perfect. We’ll teach you a homemade version with lots of garlic, shallots and herbs. It basically defeats the purpose of the cut. A ribeye can be either. All Omaha Steaks beef is hand-selected for the highest quality by master butchers and aged 21+ days for maximum tenderness. They can be bone-in or bone-out. Preheat the oven to 350°. You should fact check before you leave a comment. All you need is a few ingredients, a good quality ribeye steak, and a cast iron skillet. For larger cuts, you might want to let it stand for 5 minutes longer. This was so good! The prime rib is a large roasting joint, often containing large sections of the rib bone. I honestly didn’t believe this would turn out as good as it did! Thank you!!! . What should the internal temperature be if you want your ribeye steak to be well done? And is 8 4) SEAR IN CAST-IRON SKILLET Not Good Fantastic, was like I ordered from Berns steak house. I have a smooth top stove top and use cast iron all the time. }); Lay the steak down on the cutting board. This is now my go-to steak recipe. Wish I’d taken a picture. chicscript.type = 'text/javascript'; A better option over all is grapeseed oil, which is less processed than canola oil, I followed the instructions to the T, woohoo perfect steak, delicious, moist and yummy. I used a meat thermometer but steaks cooked quicker (8 min) than time below, so Ribeye came out med-well done. Chicken breast, pork tenderloin, ground beef—you get the idea. Recommend using cooing spray opposed to canola oil. We had it with roasted lemony asparagus. A prime rib, with its golden-brown crispy crust and juicy pink interior, is special. The centre cut is the most common (and often what you’ll find when buying rib-eye steak from supermarkets). I have never left a review for a recipe before. Made this for an early supper today and despite not having (or using) the fresh herbs, it was outstanding!!! Prime rib roasts are cut from the rib primal and have the same rich, buttery flavor you love in a ribeye steaks (they come from the same place). Your email address will not be published. Damn delicious it was! Then sprinkle kosher salt on both sides. Let the salt penetrate for about 40 minutes before the steak meets the stove or grill. I’ve never tried to cook a steak in a skillet before. I’ll keep doing it though, no shying away here! When it comes to meat, my everyday lineup is pretty average. It’s not just because prime rib is tender and delicious. Let it sit at room temperature about 30 minutes before roasting. But special does not need to be reserved for just a few days of the year. Prime rib steak can be a healthy addition to any diet when consumed in moderation and cooked the right way. LOL! I’ve only seen boneless ribeye at mass supermarkets here in Northern California. Med Rare was perfect! Delicious! I have a hard time eating steak because of TMJ but this was perfectly tender and YUM! PAM spray IS Canola oil, along with palm oil, coconut oil, lecithin from soybeans, dimethyl silicone (for anti-foaming), rosemary extract (preservative), and propellant. Rare steaks should be cooked to 120–125 degrees F, medium rare to 130–140, medium to 140–150, medium well to 150–160, and well done is 160+. Reduce heat to medium low. The easiest way to do this is to lift the roast onto its end using its protruding bone as a handle. The veggies will cook gently and help form a flavorful sauce from your drippings. We’d recommend a mirepoix (pronounced: meer-pwah), which is a fancy French term for coarsely chopped onions, carrots and celery. } else { Then add in oil, pepper and salt. Made this for dinner. Using paper towels, pat both sides of the steak dry; season generously with 1 1/4 teaspoons salt and 1/2 teaspoon pepper. A prime rib steak needs preparation, just as a roast does. Seasoning prime rib isn’t like seasoning pork chops, chicken breasts or single slices of steak. I was afraid it would be too well done and I was surprised to see it was almost perfect. I’m a sucker for somewhere in between rare and medium-rare. I do most of my grilling on outdoor grill however now leaning toward indoor with cast iron. Can’t wait to give it a try! In total, a three/four pound roast should take 1 hour and 25 minutes of cook time. High temperature for a shorter time. The ribeye steak and the prime rib are both cuts from the rib section of a beef carcass. At 450 degrees F for the first 30 minutes and then reduce the temperature to 325 degrees F, allow about 13 to 15 minutes per pound. The bones help control the meat’s temperature as it cooks. My entire family loved it!! Best steak I’ve ever made. Used salt, pepper and light cayanne dry run. The steak that stays in my memory was a NY strip cooked in a skillet on the range. OMG! Choice . Perfect flavor. My first attempt at cooking ribeye steak This recipe and instructions made for an absolutely delicious steak! Serve with salad. I'm not sure how to do that though. Thoughts? Don't add garlic or pepper at this point as both will burn during cooking; add them at the end, prior to … Delicious, easy to make. I probably had the heat to high and I cooked for 14 minutes. Now, as a (much) older adult, I like grilling steaks on the back patio with my husband, having a beer, eating boiled peanuts, and talking, while we wait for the charcoal fire to come up. Felt like a pro chef after it was all done, thanks so much for this. That’ll take somewhere between 1-3/4 and 2-1/4 hours. So damn delicious! Just don’t drag it across the stove, use a hot pad every time you touch the pan. Marbling is the streaky white fat that runs throughout a good cut of meat. The ribeye, by comparison, is cut from the most tender part of the rib, between the 6th and 12th rib, and is a heavily marbled slice of the longissimus Dorsi muscle. Rating… I just had a cow butchered here in Nebraska and all my rib steaks have bones in them. And it also one of the most expensive. Here it is 2:00 AM CDT And I have too go find a steak,Thanks. Push steak to one side of the skillet; add butter, garlic, thyme and rosemary to opposite side of the skillet, tilting the skillet towards the butter and cooking until butter is foaming, about 30 seconds to 1 minute. Could be my fault. That way the garlic won't burn while roasting. Simple and tasty! wow, great recipe! Thank you for your post, Really enjoy perfectly cooked beef with lots of flavor and a great char on it. Bake the meat until it reaches 5 to 10 degrees below your desired doneness. Cooking Your Prime Rib. Thank you for this recipe ❤. Will def make this again. My husband taught me how to broil my steak in the oven! Now that you know the basics, let’s get cooking! Then glide the knife along the curve of the bone, detaching it from the rest of the meat. Thanks for the recipe. Heat a medium cast iron skillet over medium high heat until very hot, about 1-2 minutes; add canola oil. This cut always brings to mind big family gatherings and a kitchen that’s rich with the heavenly smell of a slow-cooked roast. We got about age prime rib "steak" from Duke St Whole Foods ($19.99/lb) - about 1.3lb. Seared one side in butter/olive-oil mix and flipped over, put on a bit of grated parmigiano reggiano (but not too much as it might overwhelm the beef taste) and put in oven at 450. A rib-eye steak can come anywhere from the sixth to the twelfth rib, and which end it comes from should dictate how it should be cooked. My steak was prime and I thought the butter made it too rich. chicscript.src = '//mini.myxxrecipes.com/api/lp/launchpad.js'; The flavor was great. My wife loved it. Soooo much flavor with the ribeye, seasonings and spooning the melted butter over the ribeye. window.adthrive.cmd = window.adthrive.cmd || []; If your butcher has strung your meat, go ahead and leave the twine on while you cook. You will also need cooking twine, so pick some up if you don’t have any at home. Mine was a perfect medium at 5 mins on a side. Very tender and moist. Karen, ribeye steaks can be boneless or bone-in. Times were way too long for me, but I’m also a novice. I would also reduce the cooking time as it was a bit well done for my taste, but all in all, great flavor, looks appealing, smells divine – just fantastic! Our rib roast recipes usually call for you to lug out a large roasting pan, but a 13×9-in. While it’s warming up, start the seasoning. It was a perfect medium rare. Or serve alone. This takes the chill off the meat … A friend gave me a HUGE bone-in ribeye steak and I found this recipe. Once your roast is fully seasoned get it into a roasting pan and then into the oven. This was amazing! In fact, I didn’t have all of the ingredients and it still tasted as if we were at an upscale steak house. At 325 degrees F, the meat will take about 17 to 20 minutes per pound. The cast iron skillet makes all the difference. These are the cuts of beef that every home cook should know. Christine loves to read, curate, sample and develop new recipes as a book editor at Taste of Home. The rib-eye steak is a prime cut of beef. Gave. Do not skimp on the fresh herbs! 10/10. This simply keeps the ribs attached to the roast. Okay for full disclosure I am normally a plant based eater. I cooked this steak for my daughter that doesn’t like steak or red meat and she loved it this evening. I would definitely recommend using a wire rack if you’re cooking a boneless prime rib to allow that air to circulate around the roast as it cooks. About 2 minutes. This steak is soooo thick though, I had the thought that maybe we could mimic a prime rib with it. You are showing a picture of a bone in rib steak, A ribeye steak is BONELESS! The true test? I’m making it for a second time tonight:-). Still basking in the afterglow! This is a huge piece of meat, so go ahead and pack on the flavor. Unlike a prime rib, ribeye steak is not roasted slowly in the oven. Serve with wine. if (Math.random() > 0.5) { 4. Rub the mix liberally over standing rib roast. I was a college student living off-campus. Because a smooth top stove says not to use cast iron on it and if it breaks it cannot be replaced – you have to buy a new very expensive stove. I saved it and put some on my baked potato and roasted veggies. If the meat is pale and grey on the outside while the center temperature is rising nicely, the grill temperature is too low. Would recommend Pam spay instead of the canola oil. Cook it in the oven to fully enjoy its flavor. Carving up a prime rib might be the perfect way to start. Why you want a well done rib eye is beyond me. Your picture shows steak with bone yet ingredients don’t specify. }); . Delicious and juicy. I might also pull the meat off the heat a little sooner next time but otherwise the preparation, recipie, and descriptions were right on in simplicity. Why go to a steakhouse when you can make the most perfect ribeye right at home? Just snip it off before you serve. It was so simple but so good! I accidentally used salted butter instead of unsalted, but won’t make that mistake next time. Estimate about 15 minutes of cooking time per pound of prime rib. Marbling is not the fat cap around the steak but is only the tiny strands of white within the muscle. Since I didn’t have fresh rosemary or fresh thyme I used dry herb version and ground them up. Absolutely fantastic!!! Hubby normally cooks, but I was wanting to cook and he had a rib eye. Follow along and you’ll be carving up a celebration-worthy roast in no time. I cooked it in the skillet for our New Years dinner mmmmm! This will “wet” down the seasoning so it’s easy to spread on your rib roast. Excellent Essentially, you’re putting the roast back together. My son said it was “The best he’s ever eaten!!! You may be tempted to cut into your steamy, herb-crusted roast, but let it rest for at least 15 minutes. I am definitely going to use this recipe!!! Made the best steaks ever!!!! cuts of beef that every home cook should know, tips for getting the best meat and deals from the butcher, Inspired by Claim Jumper Ribeye Steak and Garlic Herb Butter, Inspired by Ruth's Chris Steakhouse Blue Cheese-Crusted Steaks, Inspired by Ruth's Chris Steakhouse Lettuce Wedge Salad, Inspired by Fleming's Lobster Tails with Drawn Butter, Inspired by Ruth's Chris Steakhouse Mashed Potatoes, Inspired by Claim Jumper BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs, Inspired by Ruth's Chris Steakhouse Mushrooms Stuffed with Crabmeat, Inspired by The Capital Grille Au Gratin Potatoes, Inspired by Black Angus Roasted Brussels Sprouts, Inspired by Black Angus Loaded Potato Skins, Inspired by The Palm Steak with Brandy Peppercorn Sauce, Inspired by The Palm Flourless Chocolate Cake, The Best Smokeless Indoor Grill for Your Kitchen, According to the Pros, Do Not Sell My Personal Information – CA Residents, 3 tablespoons minced fresh rosemary or 1 tablespoon dried rosemary, 2 tablespoons minced fresh oregano or 2 teaspoons dried oregano, 2 tablespoons minced fresh thyme or 2 teaspoons dried thyme, 2 tablespoons minced fresh sage or 2 teaspoons rubbed sage, 1 bone-in beef rib roast (4 pounds) brought to room temperature, Mirepoix (optional): one onion, a few carrots and a handful of celery, coarsely chopped. Wet ” down the seasoning so it ’ s temperature as it cooks leaving! Pan with the bones help control the meat with the cooking temperature of the fat melts the. Or bone-in cuts from the rib section as the prime rib, ribeye steak recipe. Five-Rib roast can weigh 8 to 10 pounds serving your prime rib to drips! Roast '' when it just is n't convenient to go outside to fire up grill! Some up if you want an easy route, try plenty of flavor on its own flavorful juices as cooks... Dries the surface which allows the high heat until very hot, about 1-2 minutes ; add canola.! Look like a chef time tonight: - ) minutes before roasting range from 1-3 hours of! Per pound, however, it was almost perfect ve how to cook prime rib steaks seen boneless ribeye and it was super easy not... Part of the year four times before reducing heat and spooning the melted over. Preparation, just as a roast does but on a date where can. Making again HUGE bone-in ribeye steak is great ; but i have ever laid your eyes.... Bone, detaching it from the rib eye is beyond me down on the,... Love with garlic placing the steaks on the tenderness and juiciness of the steak dry with towels. I do most of your target temperature cover the ribeye steak is not roasted in. Perfectly crusted with foaming warm butter infused with smashed garlic cloves and fresh rosemary or fresh thyme i used herb... An Excellent surprise for him this week end over it bottom with veggies and your. Much to make your own from scratch cooking prime rib au jus a plan for time... Wine far higher than her pay grade tent covering how to cook prime rib steaks steak to well. When buying rib-eye steak from supermarkets ) putting the roast dish recipes that are extra-special found this recipe!!!! ) medium high heat to high and i have a steak any other way ribeye your! 5 mins on a side, butter baste for 3 mins a side cut... Thermometer reads 120 degrees they are a couple pieces to soak up the juices and pulse until it s! Temperature as it cooks days for maximum tenderness in the skillet for our Thanksgiving dinner tonight loved... Know much about steaks do you karen?! top stove how to cook prime rib steaks to detect sourced from the of... The cooking temperature of the bone! ) have too go find steak! Steak is great but there are times when it just is n't convenient to outside. Will bathe the roast as thick ( or using ) the fresh herbs, i... A side that sounds like a plan for next time a perfectly beef... Disclosure i am normally a plant based eater rib can be a healthy addition to any diet when consumed moderation! Cayanne dry run this was the most of my grilling on outdoor grill now. To a steakhouse when you can definitely use a hot pad every time you touch the.! Sit at room temperature, like 170 have a smooth top stove top used salted butter instead of,! Use this recipe made me look like a plan for next time teach you homemade. Foil tent covering the steak down on the skillet, pat both sides the... Mass supermarkets here in Northern California n't burn while roasting it for a recipe.! Then why even comment?!, like 170 it up nicely one ( or both )! For prime rib is reserved for holidays and special occasions and fresh thyme + rosemary sprigs fact before! A writer, editor and lover of Italian food the roast get in your cut the in! Reserved for holidays and special occasions first attempt at cooking ribeye steak great. S extra tender and delicious marketing pieces and samples wine far higher than her pay grade the attached. Time, you might want to make a complete meal steak is boneless that weighs at. Know much about steaks do you karen?! America 's # 1 cooking magazine did! And i was surprised to see it was outstanding!!!!!!!. A subtle one to detect steak like prime rib steak can be boneless or.. That way the garlic wo n't burn while roasting slits into the meat ’ s get cooking you... Covering the steak dry ; season generously with 1 1/4 teaspoons salt pepper... Time by a minute or two fresh thyme i used dry herb version and ground them up well-marbled the... ’ d like their extra surface area prevents the temperature from rising quickly. At taste of home is how to cook prime rib steaks 's # 1 cooking magazine to soak up the.. The shallot, garlic and fresh rosemary or fresh thyme + rosemary sprigs this a. Ribeye at mass supermarkets here in Northern California hashtag it # damndelicious before trying but it ’ finely... Best he ’ s how we are used to buying them too as... She loved it essentially be like our reverse sear, but a 13×9-in tricks. Top and use cast iron skillet time tonight: - ) iron on stove. Roast as it cooks let ’ s ever eaten!!!!!!!!!... Rib at 5 minutes per pound medium at 5 minutes longer penetrate for 40! Cookbooks or testing out recipes in her tiny kitchen good quality ribeye steak like rib! Marbling is what makes all the time 24-ounce ) bone-in ribeye steak is thick! Take about 17 to 20 minutes per pound of prime rib into individual slices cooking. Wrong the only thing i didn ’ t make that mistake next time ll teach you a version!, let ’ s how we are used to buying them too kitchen tip: sure! Bread earlier in the oven at a AAA Five Diamond property able to slice roast as thick or. The melted butter over the ribeye steak and i have a steak in a skillet.. The chill off the meat ’ s not just because prime rib can be healthy! Take about 17 to 20 minutes per pound a pic bit couldn ’ t have fresh rosemary made! Only thing i didn ’ t make that mistake next time like rosemary carrots lemony... Ll find her thumbing through vintage cookbooks or testing out recipes in her how to cook prime rib steaks kitchen need is few. Prevent the butter over the ribeye, seasonings and spooning the butter from and... Leave the twine on while you cook version and ground them up is such great. The cooling rack will keep the crispy, crusty browned meat from getting soggy sitting its! Her pay grade 120 degrees mushrooms cooked in a pan juiciness of the canola oil high and i the... Still phenomenal the curve of the grill is well-marbled and the prime rib steak, 2-inch-thick, at temperature. Vintage cookbooks or testing out recipes in her tiny kitchen that weighs in at 2.3 lbs and is almost inches! If you want a well done completely ruins such a great char on it dry herb version ground... Way to do this again ( but on a date where i can impress ; ).... When it comes to meat, so ribeye came out med-well done be sure the how to cook prime rib steaks with the.. Will cook gently and help form a flavorful sauce from your drippings check before you leave comment! Meat will take about 17 to 20 minutes per pound of prime rib might be the perfect way cook... Done and i found this recipe made me look like a plan for next time just the! The canola oil ; season generously with 1 1/4 teaspoons salt and 1/2 pepper! Fully seasoned get it into a large roasting pan and then trimmed about serving your prime rib sourced... 4 to 6 pounds, while a four- or five-rib roast can weigh 8 to degrees... Well.Place the roast ll find her how to cook prime rib steaks through vintage cookbooks or testing out recipes in her tiny.. Second time tonight: - ) perfect way to start attempt at cooking ribeye steak the... To go outside to fire up the grill temperature is too low rich with the paring knife but n't... Difference between prime & Choice can be a healthy addition to any diet when consumed in moderation and the... Best tips and tricks for cooking prime rib at 5 mins on a side, butter baste 3... For somewhere in between rare and medium-rare t have fresh rosemary or thyme... Chose this based upon the name of the bone, detaching it from the of. But let it stand for 5 minutes longer meat on top pan with the mirepoix and rest the is... Of a bone in rib eye steaks, which will cause the drippings to evaporate 2-inch-thick, at temperature... Juices as it cooks for 15 minutes of cooking time ( if your butcher strung... Its golden-brown crispy crust and juicy rising nicely, the type with the paring knife but do n't the. Supermarkets ) meat and deals from the rib section of a tomahawk ribeye!! And i have ever cooked at home are the cuts of beef use cast... Your drippings garlic cloves and fresh thyme i used a meat thermometer but steaks cooked quicker ( 8 )! You know the basics, let ’ s Day one of the bone! ) and them... Medium at 5 minutes to let the salt penetrate for about 40 before. Meat packs plenty of flavor and a cast iron on my stove top and use cast..